From Scott Bumbaugh:

Nellie Belle Bumbaugh was born 22 April 1881 in McKeesport, Allegheny County, Pennsylvania, and died
18 September 1948 in Grandview, Washington County, Pennsylvania.  She was the daughter of John Wesley
Bumbaugh and Malissa J. Schnatterly.
 
Nellie first married Frank Butler on 16 April 1903 in McKeesport, Allegheny County, Pennsylvania. 
Frank Butler was born 5 October 1879 in Allegheny County, Pennsylvania.  [I don't know if Frank died,
or if he and Nellie divorced.  I have not been able to ascertain whether they had any children.]
 
Nellie then married Frank Baldwin about 1909.  Frank Baldwin was born about 1873 in Pennsylvania, and
died 8 April 1951.  Nellie and Frank Baldwin had two children:
 
1.)  Myrtle L. (P.) Baldwin, born about 1911, probably in Carroll Township, Washington County,
Pennsylvania.  She married William Hunt.
 
2.)  Robert Baldwin, born about 1924, probably in Washington County, Pennsylvania.
 
Information on first marriage to Frank Butler is from marriage license information from the Allegheny
County, Pennsylvania Courthouse in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.  The marriage is registered in Series E
#7096 volume 62 page 816.  They were married by James E. Walker.
 
The question is, when did Frank and Nellie get a divorce, and where?  Or did he die before 1909?  By
1910, Nellie is married to Frank Baldwin.
 
Wedding announcement in "The Daily News", McKeesport, Allegheny County, Pennsylvania, dated Thursday,
16 April 1903.  It reads:  Butler-Bumbaugh Wedding.  The residence of Mr. and Mrs. John W. Bumbaugh,
West Fifth avenue, will this evening be the scene of a wedding ceremony.  The contracting parties are
Miss Nellie, daughter of Mr. and Mrs. Bumbaugh, and Frank Butler, also of this city.  The ceremony
will be performed by Rev. James E. Walker, pastor of the Atlantic Avenue United Presbyterian church. 
A wedding supper will be spread to the guests after the marriage is performed and a reception held. 
Both the young people are popular.  The bride is one of the willing workers in the various societies
of the Atlantic Avenue United Presbyterian church.
 
Wedding announcement in "The Daily News", McKeesport, Allegheny County, Pennsylvania, dated Friday,
17 April 1903.  It reads:  Butler-Bumbaugh Wedding.  The home of Mr. and Mrs. John W. Bumbaugh, West
Fifth avenue, was the scene last evening at 8 o'clock of a pretty wedding event when Rev. James E.
Walker, pastor of the Atlantic Avenue United Presbyterian church, performed the ceremony uniting in
marriage their daughter, Miss Nelle Bumbaugh and Mr. Frank Butler.  There was a large crowd of
relatives and intimate friends present and after the nuptial knot was tied an excellent wedding
supper was served and a reception held in honor of the happy couple.  Both the bride and groom are
popular and well known, the bride being an energetic church worker and a member of the choir of the
Atlantic Avenue United Presbyterian church.  For the present the bridal pair will board, but as soon
as a suitable house can be obtained they will go in housekeeping.
 
Obituary for Nellie B. Bumbaugh in "The Daily News", McKeesport, Allegheny County, Pennsylvania,
dated Monday, 20 September 1948.  It reads:  Mrs. Nellie B. Baldwin.  Mrs. Nellie Bumbaugh Baldwin,
67, died Saturday at 4:12 p.m. in the home of her daughter, Mrs. William Hunt, Grandview, Washington
County, after an illness of three months.  Born in the Tenth Ward of McKeesport on April 22, 1881,
Mrs. Baldwin resided in Donora and Grandview for 35 years.  She was a member of the Union Sampson
Church and the Auxiliary to the Veterans of Foreign Wars.  Survivors include a daughter, Mrs. Hunt; a
son, Robert Baldwin of Grandview; a sister, Mrs. Alverda Harrison of Dravosburg; three brothers,
George and Grant Bumbaugh of McKeesport, and Charles Bumbaugh of Lorain, O.; and two grandchildren. 
Friends are being received at the Lawson Funeral Home in Donora where funeral services will be
conducted tomorrow at 2 p.m. by the Rev. R.A. Unger.  Interment will be in Richland Cemetery,
Dravosburg.
 
Nellie Belle Bumbaugh is buried in the Richland Cemetery with her parents.  This information was
provided by burial records from Richland Cemetery.
 
Death certificate for Malissa Schnatterly Bumbaugh.  Nellie signed the death certificate "Nellie
Baldwin" and indicated that she was living in Donora, Pennsylvania (Washington County) in 1924.
 
1910 census for Carroll Township, Washington County, Pennsylvania, dated 25 April, page 67, lines 43,
44, 45.  It lists Frank Baldwin (aged 37, PA, parents born in PA; painter), wife Nellie B. (aged 29,
PA; father born in WV, mother born in PA), and brother Jesse Baldwin (aged 27, PA, parents born in
PA, driver for a brewery).  The census indicates that both Frank and Nellie had been married twice,
and that they had only been married one year.
 
1920 census for Carroll Township, Washington County, Pennsylvania, dated 26 January, page lines 64,
65, and 66.  It lists Frank Baldwin (aged 47, PA, parents born in PA, carpenter), wife Nellie (aged
38, PA, parents both born in PA), and daughter Myrtle (aged 8, PA).
 
1930 census for Carroll Township, Washington County, Pennsylvania, page 3 A, line 22, enumerated 3
April.  It lists Nellie Baldwin (aged 48, PA), and her son Robert (aged 6, PA).  Nellie indicated
that she was married at age 22.  Where is her husband?  She was employed as a housekeeper for a
private family.  She indicated on the census that her father was born in West Virginia, and her
mother in Pennsylvania.  She also indicated that Robert's father was from Pennsylvania.  Of note,
there is another Baldwin family (Harry Baldwin) living two doors down from Nellie (line 16).  Are
they related families?